As the 2024 MLB season approaches, the Kansas City Royals find themselves at a pivotal juncture in their quest for success. With the team opting not to pursue another closer via trade, the decision on who will take on the crucial role falls on three pitchers: Will Smith, John McMillon, and James McArthur. While all three bring their unique strengths to the table, the wisest choice for the Royals appears to be the seasoned veteran, Will Smith.

Smith’s experience and success make him the most reliable option for handling the crucial role.

Will Smith boasts an impressive 11-year career, demonstrating a track record of success in the closer role. His extensive experience in high-pressure situations has equipped him with the mental fortitude required to handle the demands of the ninth inning. Smith has accumulated 611.0 innings pitched throughout his career, tallying 719 strikeouts with a solid 3.60 ERA and 1.224 WHIP.

McMillon’s limited sample size, on the other hand, reveals a promising pitcher with great potential.

John McMillon, with just one year of professional experience, shows promise with a 2.25 ERA in 4.0 innings pitched. However, the small sample size and lack of an extensive track record in high-leverage situations make it challenging to rely on McMillon as the primary closer for the Royals. The ninth inning demands consistency and a proven ability to deliver under pressure, elements McMillon may need more time to develop.

McArthur’s potential but uncertain reliability could hinder the team’s success in crucial moments.

James McArthur, with one year under his belt, presents intriguing potential with a 4.63 ERA in 23.1 innings pitched. While he showcases promise, the limited sample size and a higher ERA than Smith raise concerns about his reliability in the closer role. The ninth inning demands a pitcher who can consistently shut down opposing batters, and McArthur may need more time to fine-tune his skills.

In the grand scheme of things, experience and proven success become paramount when selecting a closer as it is a role that demands unwavering confidence and precision. Will Smith’s 11-year tenure and impressive statistics position him as the safest bet for the 2024 Kansas City Royals. While both McMillon and McArthur show promise, the risk associated with their limited experience makes them less reliable options for the crucial ninth-inning role. The Royals would be wise to leverage Smith’s seasoned expertise as they navigate the challenges of the upcoming season.